This post and this post got me the most negative comments yet on my humble little blog. Let me say first that I figured I’m so insignificant in the blogosphere that nobody’d bother arguing with me anyway, so the appearance of a few negative comments comes as a surprise.
That said, both of the referenced posts deal with visiting massive retaliation upon populations who continue to harbor and dispatch terrorists. I said that the presence of polling data to the effect that 93% of Muslim populations support terrorist kidnappings, and by default the cold-blooded killings of hostages, this data indicated sufficient justification for vigorous retaliatory strikes against those who celebrate these acts.
Now, anybody who knows me knows that I like people. I am generally an easy-going, jovial type. I give the benefit of the doubt in most cases where many others would ascribe malice. I love children and families. I wear the thick veneer of civilization as a result of several decades of peace and harmony.
But that veneer is wearing thin. Let’s just cut to the big one, 9-11-01. Three thousand Americans went to work that morning, moms and dads and sons and daughters, and they did not have the opportunity to do a normal thing: go home that evening. Several civilians in Iraq were there to work, ostensibly to help bring Iraq farther into the present than the country’d been before. Some of those civilians were forcible captured and murdered in a most hideous manner. A bunch of children go to school one morning in Russia. Some days later, their captors raped and tortured some of these children, and murdered many, many others as the situation ends.
And that veneer of civilization wears very thin.
Let’s carry the argument to its logical end point. Imagine me standing with MY children, my beloved Bonnie and Corey. Further imagine that some jihadi is threatening harm on MY children in the same manner that he has harmed others, only he hides behind “innocents”, depending on my innate reluctance to harm these innocents in my endeavor to stop him. Do you honestly think I am going to idlly stand by and allow him to aim a rifle at MY children from between the bodies of his own, and NOT act to save MY children? You can bet that upon the expenditure of my last cartidge, I would give up my last breath in the bayonet charge to save my children.
Yes, I do hate the idea of harming non-combatants. But, dear readers, I do not hate that idea as much as I hate the idea of having not done everything to protect my own family.
9-11-01 made some things perfectly clear to any lucid mind: Radical Islam is not content with keeping the fight within its borders. They do not hold to Western ideas of combatant and non-combatant, nor do truces or an idea of “fair play” have a place in their actions. There is none among them whom we can capture or coerce to sign a “surrender document” to end the war as Germany and Japan did in 1945.
We as a nation keep trying to believe that this war can be fought like the old wars, that at some time in the future, that we’ll capture the “big cheese”, be it Osama bin Ladin or one of his followers-on. And when this guy shows up on world television, the rest of the jihadis will simply say “That’s it. they got us. We quit. We’ll go home.” We want to believe that when we sit down at the table to bargain with the leaders of one group or the other, that when an agreement is reached with that one, that ALL his followers will say, “Well, he says stop, so we stop.”
And folks, aside from those in the diplomatic corps and those blinded by the diplomatic corps, nobody really believes this. To use a tired phrase, this is a new paradigm. Many in leadership, especially the military, recognize this. It’s a new kind of war? No, it’s a very OLD kind of war. Mohammed himself would have recognized what will ultimately be necessary.
And here’s a quote from a participant,
“The spectacle of Zarqawi beheading and killing Americans must not be tolerated anywhere in the world,” Gen. Glosson said. “If you don’t make them pay a penalty for it, more idiots will try it.” Gen. Glosson said the U.S. military made three mistakes: not destroying the elite Republican Guard, some of whose officers now lead the insurgency; disbanding the regular Iraqi army, pushing its soldiers toward the insurgency; and stopping U.S. Marines in April as they were clearing Fallujah of terrorists.
(Lifted from this piece over at Jenn Martinez’s place.)
I recognize this, as do many like me, some bloggers, a lot more just plain ol’ Americans who would stand in front of THEIR children and cry real tears for the dead children of the enemy.